Students are nominated to be All-Americans by their coaches and the Regional Director. Selection varies by sport.

The NJCAA All-American Award shall recognize the most outstanding student-athlete in his/her sport, regardless of geographical location. The NJCAA All-American Award shall reflect the excellence of junior college athletics by identifying our finest athletes. As well, those chosen should also exhibit the qualities of good sportsmanship and citizenship as endorsed by the NJCAA. In doing we enhance the image of all NJCAA programs and our student-athletes. NJCAA Philosophy Statement - Handbook